tisdag 9 september 2014

The Not-So-Good of Philip K. Dick


Of course I love Phil Dick also. Even when he was bad he could be interesting. And as for his outright good ones, here's my appreciation of them on Motpol, in Swedish. But in the blog post you're now reading I'm going to list some Dick books I disagree with.




The five worst Philip K. Dick Novels, how about that for a controversy? Again, let me just say that I generally adore Dick. Make no mistake about it. But here I've decided to seek out the worst books by PKD.

And here they are.



1.

A Maze of Death -- you've got it, death-death, desolation and drug-induced paranoia such as insects with guns... However, there's energy and drive to it, the setting, though depressing, has some depth. Although a hackwork this novel, being written by Dick, kinda "radiates quality". A novel about God and prophets, it has its moments but overall it's something of an oddity. Read Galactic Pot-Healer instead, it's got a modicum of optimism.


2.

Dr. Bloodmoney or how We Got Along after The Bomb -- in short: you can't write about The Bomb. It goes beyond human drama, then as well as now.



3.

The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch -- all in all a rather fine book but I'm bothered by the setting in an Earth plagued by scorching sunshine. It doesn't contribute to the story, other than saying we shall pity the characters.



4.

Eye in The Sky -- again a good book compared to many others, however the framing of the characters (right-wing guy, prissy secretary, religious fanatic) is a bit too clever-clever, a Simpson's-like satire, i. e., not hard-hitting at all. And all the railings against religion are trite; later on Dick learned better in that respect.



5.

The Man in the High Castle -- Nazis bad, Japs innately good, now that's "a bedtime-story for the children of the damned" I'd say. OK, it's wrong to call this a bad book. In fact it's got most of the marks of a classic. But I freak out on the implicit antiwhiteness of it all.



Coda

Virtually without comment, Dick novels to read are: The Game-Players of Titan, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep (mid section great, the basis for the film Blade Runner), Flow My Tears, the Policeman Said (anti-Nixon but overall great) Time out of Joint and Selections From the Exegesis (ed. Sutin).




Related
Counter-Currents: My Notes on Heinlein
Jünger and the Craft of Science Fiction





Related in Swedish
van Vogt
The Man In The High Castle
Dick: Vad är verkligt?
Dickish
Paranoid science fiction
Katedralbyggare och kritiker
Adams, Dick, Donaldson...
Jim Ballard

1 kommentar:

Svensson sa...

The five best of PKD, which ones are they? -- I'd say The Game-Players of Titan, Flow My Tears, We Can Remember It For You Wholesale, Time Out of Joint and Valis.

Etiketter

A-Z (5) abb (84) abbm (6) abbX (4) ahma (6) aktuellare böcker (59) aktufall (21) alga (3) Andersson (2) Antropolis (19) apatia (10) ar (28) att vara Svensson (236) Ballard (11) begr (7) berättelser från Rokkana (14) Bhagavad-gîtâ (6) bilbabbel (20) bild (12) bim (10) bing (287) biografi (16) bloggish (60) Blue Öyster Cult (4) camo (4) Castaneda (22) conspi (5) Den musiske matlagaren (14) Dick (7) dune (8) Eld och rörelse (33) en gatas melankoli (11) En novell om Babylon (4) eng (4) eso (3) esoterica (116) etni (3) fall (4) fantasi-fantaså-fantasy (20) film och TV (42) flytten (3) gambla fiina versepos (4) gld (7) grek (10) Gripenbergs sol (4) heinlein (4) historia in nuce (121) hårdrocken rockar hårt (39) intr. mus (34) inva (1) ipol (48) italia (3) japan (3) Jünger (75) Jüngers liv (10) Kierkegaard (2) konsten att slå en tennisserve (17) Kristus (22) kuro (2) libyen (18) link (30) lite litteratur (97) ljus (6) Lovecraft (15) Maiden (9) mangs (2) Melinas resa (8) memoarer (9) mena (40) multiversums mytolog (5) natio (63) Nietzsche (4) niven (3) nuochda (1) Ohlmarks (5) ondit (15) oneline (1) ori ett lag (53) poesy (47) politikka (177) pr (46) pred (3) Priest (14) prophecy (19) rymd (2) sanskrit (11) sf man minns (100) small candies (142) Smaragdeburg (5) speng (6) stein (4) Stratopias gåta (63) survi (6) svens11 (10) Sveriges störste poet (8) Swedenborg (3) symbol (4) Syrien (17) tempel (27) Tolkien (4) topp5 (9) typer (16) USA (17) uselt (8) van Vogt (9) Vandra mot ljuset (1) vju (4) zeppelin (2)